My Ultimate Fantasy Future Ex-Boyfriend: The Game (Part One)
I’m going to admit it right up front, I hate dating. I’ve done a lot of it, mostly in New York, and while I’ve wound up with a couple of nice boyfriends my statistics would suggest it’s a losing proposition…for me. That’s why anytime I see something I like, someone who captures my loser-magnet gravitational pull, I dub him my future ex. Best-case scenario, from a historical perspective, that’s what he’ll be.
I haven’t always been so jaded. Like Janet Livermore, Bridget Fonda’s naïve character in Singles, I used to have a list of things I looked for in a man.
1. Employed
I didn’t care so much what the job was, janitor or journalist, just so long as the guy had somewhere to go and something to do from day to day…and at least a modest income. I used to live in Williamsburg and I was particularly looking to avoid two similar strains of young men—the trust-funded and the lay-about. The former, in my opinion, had no real perspective on life and the latter was not at all interested in gaining one. Furthermore, men without drive are not the kind of men you want to get into the habit of sleeping with, or so went my logic.
2. Hygienic
Me, I like a good bather. Either I don’t know how to rationalize this one or I don’t understand why I need to. I never did get you, dirty boys. I know it’s a look, but what is it saying? Are you too high? Too lazy? Too constantly inspired by your own brilliance to give yourself a wash? Not interested.
3. Coiffed
I’m not talking about a pompadour here, just a haircut. I’ve always felt that if a man cannot choose and maintain a haircut—be it a ponytail, a buzz cut, or an afro—there’s something indicative of other character flaws in that inability…to commit.
4. Aware
This does not apply to blind dates, but if you want to go out with me I always felt you should have at least an inkling of how fantastic I am. In New York, especially, men and women scam and hook up for so many different reasons. If you’re going to the trouble of dating though, you should probably have some interest in the other person’s…interests…and perhaps less concern over their look, or job, or income, or sexual ease. I know all of these things come together in one’s subconscious calculation of attraction, but if you’re looking to see this person again and again and again it might be cool to, you know, dig what she’s about.
For a long time that was my Livermore list. Some of my friends laughed at it and others thought it was obsolete, “Hillery, who would consider anyone missing any of those things?” Then over time and for no particular reason, like Janet, I condensed the list considerably. When people would ask me what I was looking for I’d say, “Oh, you know, someone who’s nice, but not dull.”
Nice and not dull? Nice and not dull isn’t even nice and a refreshing change of pace. Nice and not dull is hoping, at best, to avoid someone who beats you but otherwise bores you to tears. Are you kidding me? Talk about reducing your expectations to the point where you’re sure you won’t be disappointed and then having to roll them back again, and again. I’m fairly sure that’s what got me to nice and not dull.
I don’t think we ever really give up our list. Experience may influence the contents and we may deny its existence, but everyone I know who’s single clings to a romantic ideal of one sort or another. I call mine my fantasy future ex-boyfriend. He’s the guy I design for myself from time to time, molded on a handful of details I might pull together about men I’ve met casually or seen on TV. My fantasy future ex interactions are often more fulfilling than those with the actual men who float through my life because they give me the rare opportunity to admit, if only to myself, what I really want in a partner…or at least what I’m craving.
This is a little game we all play from one degree to another. What I find interesting is that in examining how we construct our ideal other we can in effect deconstruct our own desires, I think. Anyway, it’s my excuse for dishing on my ultimate fantasy future ex-boyfriend. Tune in next time for: The Girl Who Loved Henry Rollins.


